Daily Management Review

iPhone Request is Unprecedented' says Apple in Court Filling


02/26/2016




iPhone Request is Unprecedented' says Apple in Court Filling
Claiming the unlocking an encrypted iPhone belonging to one of the San Bernardino shooters would violate its free speech rights and override the will of Congress, Apple Inc struck back in court against a U.S. government demand which has been demanding the unlocking of the phone.  
 
Ever since the U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation obtained a court order requiring Apple to write new software and take other measures to disable passcode protection and allow access to shooter Rizwan Farook's iPhone, high-stakes fight between Apple and the government has burst into the open.
 
This fight has again raised a long-running debate over how much law enforcement and intelligence officials should be able to monitor digital communications.
 
Apple said in its court brief that software was a form of protected speech and thus the Justice Department's demand violated the constitution, the IT company said that the court should throw out the order that it issued last week.
 
"The government's request here creates an unprecedented burden on Apple and violates Apple's First Amendment rights against compelled speech," the company said.
 
Noting that Congress had rejected legislation that would have required companies to do the things the government is asking Apple to do in this case, Apple also contended that the court was over-stepping its jurisdiction.
 
"No court has ever authorized what the government now seeks, no law supports such unlimited and sweeping use of the judicial process, and the Constitution forbids it," Apple said in its filing.
 
The government argues that apple is compelled to comply with the court order due to the All Writs Act, a broad 1789 law which enables judges to require actions necessary to enforce their own orders.
 
A key U.S. Supreme Court case, which involved a telephone company, to the San Bernardino situation had been wrongly applied by the prosecutors, Apple argued in its filing. Apple said it should not be forced to help the government hack into the San Bernardino iPhone since Apple is not a utility, and because Congress declined to force companies like Apple to build "backdoors" into their products.
 
The order from the federal court in Riverside, California last week was won by the Justice Department without the company present. While a detailed hearing is scheduled for next month, the judge allowed Apple to respond in the brief on Thursday.
 
Apple seems to have found support for its stand from some of the largest tech companies. briefs would be filed in support of the iPhone maker by both Google and Facebook, said several sources familiar with the matter who were not authorized to speak publicly about it.
 
Microsoft President Brad Smith said in congressional testimony Thursday that the company would file a friend-of the-court brief as well. Twitter also said it will sign a brief in support of Apple.
 
Its approach to prosecuting crimes has not changed, the Justice Department said in a statement responding to Apple's filing.
 
"The change has come in Apple's recent decision to reverse its long-standing cooperation in complying with All Writs Act orders," department spokesperson Melanie Newman said.
 
(Source:www.reuters.com) 






Science & Technology

Some Information About Their Self-Driving Car Research Has Been Disclosed By Apple Scientists For The First Time

A Massive Data Breach Was Covered Up By Uber By Paying Up Hackers

A City Is Can Be Converted To A Living Organism, Showcases China’s Huawei

Workers Would Be Helped To Lift More By These Robotic Vests

British Parliament to assess impact of e-cigarettes

Wind energy will provide 30% of Europe's needs by 2030

A Major Platform For Artificial Intelligence Is Its Mobile Devices: Apple

Rumor: Apple will release a budget version of iPhoneX

With China Set To Dominate, 1 Billion Could Be Using 5G By 2023

Deutsche Telekom unveils next gen 5G mobile antennas in Europe

World Politics

World & Politics

Trump: "North Korea supports terrorism"

U.S. Auto Demands Sees NAFTA Nations Locking Horns Even As The Fifth Round Comes To An End

North Korea Is Now Officially A State Sponsors Of Terrorism According To The U.S. Administration

Japan demands to lift embargo on food from Fukushima

Bernard Arnault clarifies on Le Monde’s “Paradise Paper” report

South Korea and the U.S. present a united front against the North Korean leadership

Europe is preparing an alternative to NATO

Ten smartest cities in the world