Daily Management Review

Cannot Pay? Die. Free Healthcare Market in India


11/06/2015


Health care in India cannot be classified conventionally. Can it be attributed neither to systems based on tax revenue, nor to those that exist at the expense of the insurance funds. Despite of presence of state-run clinics in the country, the government spends on health 1.3% of GDP (according to the World Bank).



Biswarup Ganguly
Biswarup Ganguly

Not surprisingly, that the vast majority of people prefer to receive care from private hands and their own money. Saurav Jha, a radiologist at hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, tells about specifics of such a health care system.

In fact, says Jha, medicine in India has become a free market. There are contracts between patients and doctors that do not require intermediaries and filling in medical records: a person pays for knowledge and ability to work with a scalpel.

Rules of the private medicine are simple, and prices - known. If you can scrape money together, you get treatment, if not - the decision is up to the doctor. This does not mean that you will not be inspected, the author notes, but the last word is said by the doctor, and that word can be "no": "Recently a hospital in Mumbai, Karuna denied a dying motorcyclist with an injury. The operation cost 20,000 rupees ($ 300), the patient did not have the 9000 ($ 136). Surgeons did not take the patient; he died".

Supporters of a more market-based health systems ignore these stories, claiming that the market does not require people to die on the street. However, when a doctor refuses to operate if surgery, it does not make the market less "market", as the key condition - the voluntary agreement between the parties - respected, says Jha. This is freedom of the Indian healthcare market: there is no controller, which would cause the surgeon to work free of charge; if a regulator appeared, the market would have become more humane, but less free. Indian surgeons claim that if they cure at least one person for free, they will be invaded by an endless stream of patients. Eventually, doctors will be left without livelihoods.

The Indian system of paid medicine even caused a demographic imbalance in the country. The development of ultrasound technology allowed doctors entrepreneurs to travel to villages and even cities with portable appliances, allowing determining sex of unborn childen in the womb. For a variety of economic reasons, a boy in India is a child coveted more than a girl, and possibility to know the sex for a few hundred rupees has led to a jump in abortions and gender imbalance of men prevailing on women in many Indian states.

Ironically, such a healthcare system, which seems inhuman to a Western man, is well suited to the Indian worldview, says Jha. Indians are fatalists and blame Gods for their woes. Unlike many Western people, they do not consider health to be a main value - most Indian will save money to spend on their daughter's wedding rather than on their own treatment in old age.

source: qz.com






Science & Technology

Tech giants face stricter government regulation in the US

Nestle's Head: Veggie meat is new megatrend

Huawei may introduce Android replacement in August

Are US high-tech investors causing brain drain in Europe?

'Russia's Google' Yandex Was Hacked By Western Intelligence For Spying: Reuters

Reuters: Chinese hackers were stealing data from IT giants for years

China's first solar power molten salt plant sets record

WSJ announces imminent start of Boeing 737 MAX flight tests

Study: Machine learning is five times more harmful for the environment than a car

Would Singapore Be The First One To Bring Lab Grown Shrimps To The Global Market?

World Politics

World & Politics

France announces new tax for air fares

Europe Concerned Over Iran Move To Breach Uranium Enrichment Cap

Singapore To Build ‘$296 Million’ Smart Next-Gen Army Training Centre

No More Sales Of E-Cigarettes In San Francisco?

US ‘Hell-Bent On Hostile Acts’ Even After Trump-Kim Agreement, Says North Korea

Italy avoids EU sanctions for high national debt

Trump allocates 4.6 bln to help migrants

Iran Says Trump’s Belief That US-Iran War Would Be Short Is “An Illusion”